welcome to the club. i've sent emails back and forth with their customer service (which got me nowhere).
i have the paid version as well and have yet to receive any push notification except for the annoying welcome message that always comes up after a reboot.
i have the following: capital one, bank of america, ticketmaster, ebay, twitter, gmail, citibank, bestbuy, sprint and the list goes on..
according to them, the person who responded to my email says that they will only send a push notification if the account status has changed/updated.. which is entirely false because Pageonce auto notified me of a late-payment charge on my Bank of America account .. thru email ONLY! and 2 days later after i got charged!
i stopped emailing them because it got nowhere .. so good luck